The Elmton in Strutders

584 5td St, Strutders, OH 44471-1846, Strutders

Overview

Cuisine
  • Italian
  • American
  • Pizza
Features
  • Takeout
  • Reservations
  • Seating
  • Waitstaff
  • Television
  • Wheelchair Accessible
  • Serves Alcohol
  • Full Bar
Good for
  • Large groups
  • Kids
  • Families witd children

Restaurant Hours

Monday

11:00 am

Wednesday

11:00 am

Friday

11:00 am

Sunday

11:00 am

Was there twice in last couple of months, the pizzas do taste different. Do not like it

Howdy from Houston. I love Elmton's pizza

I live in Atlanta and I was wondering if you could ship pizzas down here?

Not sure...call them.

I keep hearing rumors that the Pizza changed. I went down and grabbed a pizza yesterday and I agree, I think they changed something. Anyone have any idea? Could it be the owners trying to cut costs due to the current issue with trying to find help?

I don't think they would cut costs, but if you have different cooks making it, there could be a difference.

Can you ship to Florida?

If they won't, let me know. Anything can be done for the right price.

Do you have soup?

Yes

Does the Elmton take reservstions

I don't think so. Call them. I've seen them be very busy but never a line. Great pizza.

Are there any gluten free items on the menu?

I doubt it, maybe wings or a deep fried veggie platter, salads, would probably be the extent of it.

Are you open Christmas Eve

Definitely call

are phone not working

They should be working.

Review

Add rating restaurant:
The Elmton
KB
Kevi B
google
11.20.2024
5/5

I ordered the broasted chicken from elmton for a work party and it was delicious.

The Elmton
KS
K Snyder
google
08.10.2018
5/5

Food is always great. I feel like this place should be on Diners, Driveins, and Dives.

The Elmton
BradlyJ03
google
07.06.2018
5/5

Always great food! Always great service! Always a great time!!! 10☆s

The Elmton
MC
Marissa Capes
google
07.05.2018
5/5

Such an amazing place to eat and wow they have home made everything! I will definently be back! So happy I tried it! The people are amazing there as well!!!!

The Elmton
JK
Jessica Keenan
google
04.24.2018
1/5

The pizza was cold and undercooked and the fried veggie platter was just smoosh. This place is getting worse and worse. The pizza used to be the best in Youngstown.

The Elmton
bl
b l
google
04.17.2018
3/5

The worst pizza I have ever had. Everything else is alright though.

The Elmton
AM
Angry Mr. Stay Puft
google
03.27.2018
5/5

you gotta be in the mood for local, dive bar food, but if you are, the Broasted Chicken has been a local delicacy for over 50 years. their pizza is also famous, but i don't care for Swiss cheese. the chicken wings, however, are in a league of their own. and that is saying something when there's Wings Express Reloaded in Hubbard and the Royal Oaks on the east side.

The Elmton
LB
Linda Benedict
google
03.10.2018
5/5

Best pizza ever! The broasted chicken is very good. The people that works there are great. Service is always very friendly. I like going there to relax and eat. You don't feel rushed. You can meet people there for lunch or dinner and eat and talk. You can enjoy your company along with the friendliness of the staff.

The Elmton
RM
Rob Mancini
google
02.16.2018
4/5

Great food, prices and service!

The Elmton
JE
Jason Evans
google
01.06.2018
4/5

Love the broasted chicken and of course the pizza is unique

The Elmton
TR
Tim Ruffo
google
01.04.2018
5/5

Dude this pizza is killer. Way better than the more popular places in town. Go sausage

The Elmton
Om
google
01.04.2018
5/5

Best pizza in Youngstown, Ohio area. Nothing compares

The Elmton
DZ
Dolores Zook
google
10.25.2017
5/5

Great pizza, as always. Did seem to be a little greasy this time though. Have been coming here since the 50s and will keep coming.

The Elmton
GY
Glen York
google
10.24.2017
5/5

The most unique legendary Pizza in our area been around forever

The Elmton
MH
Michael Hodge
google
10.06.2017
5/5

Arguably best pizza in youngstown area.

The Elmton
NC
Nikki Calabret
google
09.07.2017
4/5

Always delicious! They have the most unique pizza recipe and the best wedding soup.

The Elmton
DG
Dave Galioto
google
08.27.2017
5/5

Go Elmton. Not sure what changed, but I went there the other day and it was the best pizza I've had in a long long time. Something is different and it now tastes more like it it did when I was a kid. I can't wait to go back for more.

The Elmton
RR
Rich Rudman
google
08.17.2017
5/5

one of the best places to order pizza, pepperoni is on top of the cheese and green peppers are added. Can't wait to try it again.

The Elmton
SZ
Shannon Zappia
google
08.12.2017
4/5

Love their Pizza and broasted wings!

The Elmton
SS
Scott Seitz
google
07.08.2017
5/5

Had a great night..Met the singer from Fins to the Left. (Jimmy Buffet tribute). Great food. Great time. This is my grandson Murphy.. says best pizza ever! Looks like he means it....

The Elmton
AH
Aino Hernandez
google
06.19.2017
3/5

Pricey but good. They rectified a messed up order I had. Good overall.

The Elmton
MB
Mark Britt sr.
google
06.17.2017
4/5

Love the elmton for events always get their barbecue chicken in a couple of those delicious pizza with that special cheese

The Elmton
TM
Tammy Malich
google
05.11.2017
5/5

Best white pizza anywhere!! We eat here every time we go in town to visit family we eat there.

The Elmton
PT
Pat Tucci
google
04.25.2017
1/5

When they brought us our order the food was not hot. So when they went to warm it up the waitress spilled it in the kitchen and we had to wait another hour for our food. Then when we got our entrees they were not very good this place has gone down hill tremendously and we will never return. Then both of us had stomach aches all night. Update. So we thought we'd give him another chance so we were there on 2/29/2020. I ordered the veal parmesan with spaghetti and as I tried to eat the veal I flipped the piece over and it was totally burned and hard as a rock. The bad part is they tried to hide the burned spot. What else are they hiding?

The Elmton
CC
Canbilly Canfield
google
04.19.2017
4/5

I gave it a 4 because i didn't get to stay long enough and try all the food. But what i did try was very pleasing. The inside was beautiful and spotless.

The Elmton
AB
Aaron Bero
google
04.12.2017
3/5

Not sure if it was just the day but the pizza was really salty, maybe from the cheese. Crust was excellent as it always is. Service was pretty good, one employee sat on the back steps as we tried to leave and wouldn't move, thought that was kind of rude.

The Elmton
ED
E D OGG
google
03.04.2017
5/5

I like to consider my self a pizza connoisseur lol i absolutely love pizza and being that ive lived in the are 20 plus years im disappointed in myself i didnt come here !!sooner absolutely phenomenal! While i was waiting for my pizza tonight i had the pleasure of speaking with a nice lady who happened to inform me her father inlaw opened the elmton 75 years ago they have always had the same recipe and never changed a thing..after tonight i completely understand why will definitely be going back many more times !!

The Elmton
DLN
google
01.15.2017
5/5

Great food, service and atmosphere!

The Elmton
RG
Raymond George
google
01.14.2017
4/5

Good service, good food, good price.

The Elmton
TF
Tara Frias
google
01.04.2017
5/5

Even tho we didn't get the pizza we order thru delivery it was still delicious! We also ordered wings and they were enormous and filled with flavor. Will definitely be ordering here again. Just hope we get the right pizza next time 😜

The Elmton
AT
Angela Thomas
google
11.15.2016
4/5

They always seem to have great pizza and sandwiches.

The Elmton
DT
David Thomas
google
11.06.2016
5/5

Great food and friendly service

The Elmton
GH
Gary Hassay
google
11.01.2016
5/5

Elmton is delicious! If you go you have to try the broasted chicken and their pizza. I don't even live in Struthers but I drive in for the chicken and pizza. YUM!

The Elmton
JJ
Jeremy Jay
google
10.24.2016
3/5

So we were here from out of town. This place was recommended by a friend. The food did NOT disappoint! Loved the pizza and the cheese sticks are a must! The prices are really reasonable as well!The reason for the 3 stars is because the service was bad. 2 1/2 hours in the restaurant waitress was not attentive. Waited for my wife's water even had to ask the bar for a water. Waitress ignored us and and didn't respond to any of our requests.If the service was on par this would be a 5 star review!

The Elmton
RM
Ralph Mack
google
10.15.2016
5/5

By far some of the best food in the area! The pizza here is incredible, and has now been my go to place at least once a week. The staff is great, with Stephanie being great at suggestions my first few times there.

The Elmton
MP
Marcus Pierce
google
10.07.2016
5/5

Great Pizza and Wings..This is an Restaurant You must try if your looking for something different with A Great taste...And the service was Definitely Friendly and Fast...

The Elmton
NR
Nora Rock
google
08.25.2016
2/5

We had terrible service. We came in at about 10:30 and they closed at 11. We asked the server lady if they could get us in really fast. We already knew our order and everything because we’ve been coming here for years. She said “Ugh I guess I could get you in” and she was already in a bad mood judging by her mean tone. She gets our order and gives us our drinks and we’re waiting for a while. So after like 10 minutes she comes to us and say we can’t serve you anymore. We were like what. She said that they didn’t have time to make us a small pizza. Now we’ve been here before and it only takes them at most 15 minutes to make a pizza here. So she made us leave. At least we didn’t have to pay for our drinks I guess. And it was saddening because we really love the food here. So my advice, don’t come an hour before closing.

The Elmton
DB
Don Bartelmay
google
08.20.2016
5/5

I have been enjoying this bar and restaurant since I was a child over 70 years ago. Went there with my parents . Best pizza in the world. Love it, great food, cold beer and good service.

The Elmton
ms
mike stanish
google
08.16.2016
5/5

Best pizza, chili dogs, and chicken salads for the last century in Youngstown, Ohio. Stop giving your money to the big chains and get the best around for less than you are used to paying for dinner.

The Elmton
SM
Shawn Mackin
google
07.02.2016
5/5

Haven't been in years, but sure happy to have gone back! Fast service, excellent food and phenomenal prices! Cant wait to go back for more pizza!

The Elmton
bc
bill csernik
google
05.10.2016
5/5

Great pizza and chicken parm.

The Elmton
GT
Gregory Tesoriero
google
05.08.2016
2/5

I’m not sure what’s going on but The Elmton used to have the best pizza in THE WORLD!! We live approx 25 miles away and we would go over two to three times a month just for a pie. (May times I said I was going to get something else but never did that’s how good it was) The last three times the pizza was different. I noticed it, my family noticed it, and so did our friends. I’m not sure what they did but there were rumors they changed the CHEESE! And if they did why? Why mess with the best of the best? It will be awhile before we go back and when we do I’ll either retract this post or add to it let’s hope for a retraction.

The Elmton
DS
David Simmons Jr
google
04.11.2016
5/5

Only my second time in Struthers!!My friend J.T. took me here.Great Food and reasonable drink prices!!

The Elmton
RG
Robert Gilliland
google
04.08.2016
5/5

Home town food, mostly Italian, with excellent pizza. Portion size leaves some to take home. Very busy. Good service.

The Elmton
CM
Chris Mastramico
google
04.01.2016
5/5

If you're not from Youngstown yet happen to be reading this, I cannot undersell this point - you will not find better pizza ANYWHERE than what you'll find in the Y. The Elmton is a prime example of a shop being at the top of their craft. The crust, the cheese blend or the sauce - take any one of those and you have yourself a fine pie, but throw them all together and you have a masterpiece. Of note, they put green pepper slices on all pizzas, so your kids will likely balk. Just tell them to grow up and enjoy life already. Or take them off the pizza, whatever works for you.

The Elmton
JB
John Burlock
google
03.01.2016
5/5

I grew up on this pizza and chicken but hadn't had it in years. Finally found my way back for a pizza and it was as delicious as I remembered. This is a Youngstown landmark which should be supported by the community for another 100 years. A+ Elmton!

The Elmton
CH
Carolyn Hollingsworth
google
02.22.2016
5/5

Love to go there. It is my all time favorite pizza. Live in Alabama now but when I go home it is a must.

The Elmton
WW
William Wolford
google
01.21.2016
4/5

Famous local favorite pizza, chicken, and much more.

The Elmton
SD
Shannon Dixon
google
01.20.2016
5/5

It was just wonderful. The cavatelli and meatballs was delicious and a great size for the price. The waitress was so kind and helpful. I can't wait to go back.

The Elmton
FC
Frank Callella
google
01.08.2016
5/5

Great place to go to eat for years always have great food and service prices are fair

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 13307558511

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!